If you’re new to the publishing world, finding an editor can be a daunting experience. Where do you look for an editor? How do you know they are reputable? Hopefully, this post will help answer those questions and give you the knowledge you need to find your partner in fictional crime.
Where to find your editor
Of course, you could simply carry out a search for ‘editor’ on Google; however, the results are going to be extensive and will need a lot of sifting through.
Word of mouth is a great way to find an editor. If you have friends who are published authors (either trad or indie), ask them who they have worked with and recommend. For those who are new to the world of publishing and don’t have contacts, there are places to look.
Reedsy is an online marketplace for freelance publishing professionals, where authors can search for editors and proofreaders. You submit a brief to those you think will be a good fit, enabling you to search for your perfect editorial partner in one place. All of the editors on Reedsy have been approved by their level of experience and expertise and, believe me, it is not easy to gain that approval and be accepted (here’s my profile).
Another place to look is the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading directory. As with Reedsy, you can be assured of the qualifications and experience of those listed because all the professionals listed are members of the CIEP.
How to determine if they are reliable
Editing is an unregulated industry, and anyone can set up a website and say they are an editor and/or proofreader. So how do you know the editor you’re thinking of hiring is reputable? Here is a list of things you can look for:
1. Are they suitably qualified?
What does this mean? Well, when I say suitably qualified, I mean they have industry recognised qualifications. In the UK this would mean they have completed courses with the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading and/or the Publishing Training Centre (PTC). If you’ve found an editor or proofreader you are considering using, ask them what qualifications they have if it’s not stated on their website and ask to see their certificates. After all, if you were hiring someone for a job in a company this would be standard practice, and it should be in this situation too as it’s the same thing. At a minimum, they should have completed some of the CIEP's or PTC's specific proofreading and copyediting courses – other courses are aimed at building on skills already obtained; not to prepare professionals to do the job of a copyeditor or proofreader.
2. Are they a member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading?
Don’t get me wrong, this isn’t mandatory and there are great editors who aren’t members; however, it tells you a lot about the editor’s experience and commitment.
An Entry-Level Member is someone who has just started out on their editorial career. They may have completed or be going through their courses to become qualified. This doesn’t mean you should rule out hiring them. Upgrading your CIEP membership takes time and they may be in the process of doing this and have the relevant qualifications and experience that you need. The CIEP states it expects its Entry-Level Members to upgrade.
An Intermediate Member has ‘laid the groundwork for providing services as a proofreader or copyeditor by undertaking high-quality training’ and has put that training into practice via work experience to ‘embed their skills’.
A Professional Member has completed ‘high-quality training … beyond the introductory level’, has had ‘editorial work experience that’s substantial in quality’, and has provided a satisfactory reference from a client or employer.
An Advanced Professional Member has completed the steps above but also ‘demonstrated a high level of skill and expertise, backed by long and broad editorial work experience and often enhanced with editorial specialisms’.
Membership is also an indication that the person takes their career seriously and believes in expanding their professional development. It also means they adhere to the CIEP’s code of practice. If the person you’re thinking of hiring is a CIEP member, they will be proudly displaying their membership badge on their website.
3. Have they been accepted on Reedsy?
Absolutely not a deal breaker, but ascertaining if the editor or proofreader you’re considering has been accepted by Reedsy is a good indicator that they are reliable and have the appropriate expertise. It’s not easy to be accepted onto the site and they only take those with a substantial amount of experience with publishers. How do you know if your editor has been approved? They will have a blue tick next to their name and a section that states they are available to hire. While you’re there, you can check out any reviews from clients who have hired them through the site.
4. Who has provided them with testimonials?
Now, I may potentially cause some offence here, and that is absolutely not my intention so please bear with me. If there aren’t any testimonials from publishing professionals, you may want to ask yourself why. Yes, it may be that they specialise in providing services to self-publishing clients. While I am not undermining the expertise of indie authors, it has to be acknowledged that the same level of experience and quality control isn’t in place within self-publishing as it is within a publishing house. Of course, there are loads of fantastic editors and proofreaders who only work with self-publishing clients, and this shouldn’t be taken in isolation but with the other three points.
The above points aren’t compulsory, and an editor doesn't have to have all four to be a good editor (I am not in the CIEP's directory because I haven't got round to completing the form yet), but they are useful to keep in mind when assessing the credentials of your potential editor.
Planning is essential
When self-publishing, it pays to think like a publishing house and that means planning ahead. In traditional publishing, it takes months to get a book ready for publication. It can be tempting to try to rush your novel out once you have finished writing it, but patience is the key. Experienced and highly regarded editors are often fully booked up months in advance. They won’t take on more projects than they can handle at a time as they want to provide the best service for you and your book. It is worth the wait to collaborate with the editor of your choice.
Sign up for helpful content, news and special offers.
You have successfully joined my subscriber list.